Note: This item is coauthored by John Kusumi and Ning Ye, a Chinese dissident and attorney. Both authors are with the pro-democracy China Support Network.
As Barack Obama prepares to welcome Hu Jintao to a White House state dinner, Zbigniew Brzezinski launched a message offensive to frame U.S.-China relations. Regrettably, the policy prescriptions are flawed, faulty, and wishful rather than realistic. They were of arguable merit in the 1970s (the decade when the policy began); they overlook geopolitical changes in the 30 years since then; and in the twenty-teen decade, they are fully divorced from reality.
During forty recent years, U.S.-China policy can be summarized by five words: getting cozy with Communist China. It is against our better interests; it is economically ruinous; and by building up a nuclear-armed, communist superpower, it directly threatens the U.S.' own national security. It is a risky scheme to have a hasty rush to Maoism.
Where does this policy come from? In large part, it comes from Zbigniew Brzezinski. He was the National Security Advisor to former U.S. President Jimmy Carter. During that term of office, the U.S. threw Taiwan under the bus and normalized relations with Beijing.
Writing in the New York Times on January 2, Brzezinski waxed nostalgic about former dictator Deng Xiaoping's historic trip more than 30 years ago, as Deng visited the Carter administration to begin collecting China's winnings. It is as though China held a winning lottery ticket. Brzezinski notes that it “marked the beginning of China's three-decades-long economic transformation – one facilitated by its new diplomatic ties to the United States.”
Brzezinski's policy advice is old wine in an old bottle. It is as though nothing has changed since November 1969, when the Cohen memo reached the desk of former U.S. President Richard Nixon and hatched the idea of getting cozy with Communist China. Because actual policy then moved in the direction suggested by Jerome Cohen's memo, subsequent pronouncements have all been oriented to reinforce and defend the indefensible policy.
The issue now is that China has risen to being the world's number two superpower, from being the poorest one among the Communist ranks 40 years ago, when U.S. policy made its strategic U-turn to enable the “younger nephew” to fight against the “big brother.”
It is always fair to note that the Communist Party is not China – and, China is not the Communist Party. U.S. policymakers have chosen to be cozy with China's government, but not with the wider aspirations of its people, best expressed in its pro-democracy, labor, and religious movements such as Falun Gong. Therefore we are really discussing U.S.-CCP relations, because the CCP is the one party, dictatorial government that stands in for China while victimizing its people, suppressing these movements, and enabling diabolical corruption.
Lip service notwithstanding, the appeasement policy of recent decades has bet against popular aspirations and against the emergence of Chinese democracy. Certainly, the U.S. would be better served with a hedging strategy. What if the CCP is on the wrong side of history? Will the U.S. be remembered for aiding and abetting some of history's worst oppressors?
If we look at policy outcomes on the ground, that's what we're doing: The U.S. is aiding and abetting some of history's worst oppressors. If we include its victims under Chairman Mao, the CCP has killed 80 million Chinese people, in addition to approximately 58,000 U.S. soldiers in the battlefields of Korea. Adding to the death toll, the brutal Falun Gong crackdown (still in progress) may be larger than the Tiananmen crackdown, the Uighur crackdown, and the Tibetan crackdown combined. For the CCP, crimes against humanity are business as usual.
In the worst case, U.S. policy is now analogous to that of Neville Chamberlain, the British prime minister of the 1930s who refused to believe the worst of Nazi Germany. Unwilling to treat the Nazi threat as the strategic, lethal adversary that it was, Chamberlain followed policies of appeasement and began to sound like Baghdad Bob, in denial of the actual military situation on the ground. It took a different British prime minister, Winston Churchill, to have a clear eyed view and to exhibit strength against Nazi Germany.
Brzezinski argues for continued, Chamberlain-esque appeasement with complete disregard to a completely changed geopolitical landscape more than 40 years after the Cohen memo. Naturally since the policy is his brainchild, he defends it with this old wine in an old bottle.
In Brzezinski's time as National Security Advisor, this policy weakened the Soviet bloc. But in the decades since then, changes of circumstance now indicate that this policy is weakening the free world.
Absent the Soviet Union, U.S.-China relations have been of, by, and for business, even while the balance of payments has tipped heavily in favor of China and against the U.S. economy. U.S. rhetoric about liberty and rights has been hollow window dressing. The stale policy benefits two groups and hurts two others. The benefit has been for U.S. and CCP elites. The harm has been for U.S. and Chinese laobaixing (a term that means “ordinary citizens”).
Brzezinski has failed to justify why the U.S. should be out of step with liberty, itself. He can no longer fall back on the Soviet Union to justify the appeasement of Communist China.
Many Chinese are themselves astonished at the winning lottery ticket that was handed to the CCP in the 1970s. Chinese dissident Wei Jingsheng has celebrated the emergence of the Tea Party in U.S. politics. If there is any hope, however slim, that America will move in a different direction, that is to be welcomed.
It is to be admitted that Zbigniew Brzezinski had his day. But now, it is time for the U.S. to dial back on its provision of aid and comfort to a nuclear armed, communist superpower.Tweet
Latest posts by John Kusumi (see all)
- Could Chuck Todd be right? - January 22, 2017
- Leading Chinese Dissident: Investigate China For Hacking! - December 16, 2016
- Criminal Meets Criminal: Barack Obama & Xi Jinping - September 24, 2015
- Spock Dies, and Logic Eludes America - February 28, 2015
- Florida Captures Activist On His Way To #Ferguson, Missouri - October 9, 2014
- Citizenship renounced / USG denounced - September 5, 2014
- Vladimir Putin, Western World Reach Their Limits - September 2, 2014
- Ireland in crisis over Garth Brooks concerts - July 10, 2014
- Commentators Snooze While America Wakes Up - September 12, 2013
- War Is On The Table, But Why? - August 29, 2013
- Occupy Wall Street May Resume As 'End Wall Street.' - August 4, 2013
- Will Egypt Prompt An American Revolution? - July 6, 2013
- 2013: Chinese revolution? - January 8, 2013
- Hu's On First? - March 23, 2012
- China, Europe, Iowa and North Korea now face splendid opportunities - December 21, 2011
- Eurocrisis and Bankster Government: Diminishing the Free World - November 14, 2011
- Investor Class Should Return To Normalcy - August 7, 2011
- Dissidents seek to derail the nomination of Gary Locke for U.S. ambassador - May 12, 2011
- The Impeachment of Barack Obama - May 7, 2011
- “Hillary Clinton, Stop this genocide!” - April 24, 2011
- Alex Jones almost gets it - April 21, 2011
- Revolution Youth Coalition calls out Clinton, highlights Obama's democracy dilemma - March 16, 2011
- High Time to Re-think U.S. China Policy - January 18, 2011
- China Policy Ossified, Wishful, Ruinous - January 14, 2011
- Obama Administration: I'm Not Impressed - December 24, 2010
- China Support Network Demands Media Apology - December 8, 2010
- All You Need To Know About The Republican Party - November 5, 2010
- American Politics in Summation, 2010 - October 31, 2010
- Nobel Prize goes to Liu Xiaobo, still in jail - October 8, 2010
- – Not Tough Enough With China! – - September 25, 2010
- CNN Falls Victim to CNN - July 1, 2010
- 21st Anniversary of Tiananmen - June 5, 2010
- One Cheer for Barack Obama - April 8, 2010
- Revisiting 9/11 - March 12, 2010
- CNN Commits Sacrilege - February 19, 2010
- PRC: Merry Christmas, Here’s 11 Years In Prison - December 25, 2009
- Why Obama Fails - December 17, 2009
- Peace Movement Says Hello World - December 14, 2009
- Dissident Wei asks why Obama “failed so much” in China? - November 20, 2009
- China Support Network writes to Obama - November 5, 2009
- Operation ‘Can You Hear Us Now’? - October 15, 2009
- News conference scolds China and Hong Kong - September 20, 2009
- This Week at the China Support Network… - September 13, 2009
- Tiananmen Persecution Continues in the Present Day - September 1, 2009
- Implications for younger Americans of the passing of Senator Ted Kennedy - August 27, 2009
- Give me death panels, or give me liberty! - August 12, 2009
- Chinese dissident leans into campaigning - August 2, 2009
- Practical Idealism on Health Reform - July 30, 2009
- Iran’s Black Day In Perspective - June 20, 2009
- The Opposite of the Right Thing - May 29, 2009
- Book Review: Standoff At Tiananmen - May 5, 2009
- Tiananmen Square Student Leader Captured - April 21, 2009
- Skepticism for New Chinese Promises on Human Rights - April 13, 2009
- Movie Review: The Obama Deception - March 20, 2009
- Barack Obama: The President of Bait and Switch - February 25, 2009
- Wei Jingsheng Writes To Hillary Clinton - February 22, 2009
- Hillary Clinton Visits Her Communist Masters In Beijing - February 21, 2009
- Media cries ‘perjury’ about Roland Burris - February 17, 2009
- I refuse to unify! - January 21, 2009
- Political Roundup 2008 - October 31, 2008
- The Economy, Stupid - October 16, 2008
- Ralph Nader responds to McCain-Obama Debate - October 8, 2008
- Tonight: Evil debates Evil, moderated by Evil. - October 7, 2008
- Bailout saga: People vs. Politicians - September 30, 2008
- American Interests: Where do we draw the lines? - September 2, 2008
- CNN Caught In Genocidal Correctness - August 25, 2008
- Biden: Smart Guy, Wrong on PNTR - August 24, 2008
- Olympics: “We find it abominable…” - August 8, 2008
- White House Talking the Talk for Chinese Democracy - August 5, 2008
- Privacy concerns, vetted and unvetted - July 8, 2008
- YouTube User Decries Spill of Video Logs - July 5, 2008
- Happy Birthday, America! - July 3, 2008
- Shame on Anderson Cooper! - May 31, 2008
- Remembering Tiananmen Square - May 30, 2008
- Diplomatic demarche called for by China Support Network - May 23, 2008
- China’s Year Of Disasters Breeds Discontent - May 16, 2008
- CNN’s Cafferty should not be demonized - April 21, 2008
- China is the new Soviet Union - April 4, 2008
- Dispatches on Tibet, China & Condi Rice - March 20, 2008
- Monster versus Monster: The Democratic Race - March 7, 2008
- Attention CNN: Please Fire Bill Schneider - March 2, 2008
- Stop PNTR for Communist China - February 25, 2008
- Dear Lou Dobbs and Jack Cafferty – an open letter - February 7, 2008
- SOTU: The Practical Idealist Response - January 29, 2008