Some of the feedback I've received on the article “An Economy on Life Support Is Not Recovering” shows a fundamental misunderstanding my critics have about the arguments presented there. In retrospect I see that a more detailed explanation is needed.
In reply to the article there are those who state what the article acknowledges, that Gross Domestic Product (GDP) grew and unemployment dropped from 1933 until 1937. This is taken as proof of the success of the New Deal. Their mistake is thinking that all GDP numbers are equal. They are not, as I explain below.
GDP growth based on private investment in productive capital is the only basis for real growth. In other words companies must invest in factories and other productive facilities (capital accumulation). This investment must come from people's savings, i.e. it must be based on real production, real resources that have been produced. In this way the economy can grow in a realistic and sustainable manner.
When the government spends untold fortunes to stimulate the economy, GDP and unemployment numbers may temporarily improve, but this improvement is illusory. All one does under this scenario is put more money out chasing a stagnant or declining supply of goods and services. The resources used in such a process are not being invested in any kind of productive facilities. On the contrary, productive facilities are being run down to support the make work projects that the government is spending tax money on. (I know that governments also spend money by running deficits, but ultimately the debts must be paid out of tax revenues. Governments can also “print” money, that is paid for with inflation)
As Frank Shostak explains in “What is up with the GDP?“:
The GDP framework cannot tell us whether final goods and services that were produced during a particular period of time are a reflection of real wealth expansion, or a reflection of capital consumption.
For instance, if a government embarks on the building of a pyramid, which adds absolutely nothing to the well-being of individuals, the GDP framework will regard this as economic growth. In reality, however, the building of the pyramid will divert real funding from wealth-generating activities, thereby stifling the production of wealth.
The whole scheme wouldn't work even if the government could spend massively forever, but, anyway, the reality is that it can't. When the day of reckoning comes and the government's spending slows the economy slows with it. This is exactly what happened in 1937.
Of course, the government could ignore the “day of reckoning” and just keep on spending, but the result then is the disaster we see in Zimbabwe today.
Hopefully, this clarifies the argument put forward in the article “An Economy On Life Support Isn't Recovering”.
In closing I'd like to anticipate the counter argument that spending on infrastructure such as roads, bridges, mass transit, and schools isn't make work but needed improvement. To a very small degree this is true, however, most of the money will be spent according to political pull rather than necessity. Politicians excel at making the usually false argument that project X in their district is of vital importance and most necessary. The reality is that they just want more pork to pass around to supporters to buy votes and campaign contributions. Remember, a bridge to nowhere is not an investment, it's a waste of resources.
I would like to thank Ralph Mullinger for reviewing this article and for his feedback.
2/25/2009 update: Reinforcing the points made above is 'Economic Recovery Requires Capital Accumulation, Not Government “Stimulus Packages”' Thank you, Professor Reisman.Tweet
Latest posts by Darren Wolfe (see all)
- An African Adventure - May 18, 2014
- Know The Enemy of Liberty: the National Rifle Association - April 30, 2014
- Imagine the Bundy Ranch Showdown With Well Regulated Militias - April 22, 2014
- Taxes and War Profiteers - April 20, 2014
- Professor Roth Says “…Guns Aren’t the Problem” - April 3, 2014
- Democratic Socialism, Guns, and the Failure of the Constitution - December 20, 2013
- Fun With Guns, Hate Mail, and Debates at an Open Carry Rally (video) - December 8, 2013
- There Is No Case for Gun Control (video and hate mail) - December 5, 2013
- Bringing Liberty to Valley Forge (video) - October 15, 2013
- No War on Syria Speech (video) - September 16, 2013
- The Standing Armies of Yesterday and the Police State Today - August 22, 2013
- Reverse Jury Nullification in the Zimmerman Trial? - July 14, 2013
- Michael Lind Is Right: Libertarianism Doesn't Work - June 19, 2013
- The Left Needs to be Leery of the IRS Too - June 7, 2013
- Smokedown Prohibition V: Adam kokesh and NA Poe Arrested (video) - May 19, 2013
- Gun Rights Activists Not Welcome in Coatesville - March 24, 2013
- Stopping Illegally Funded Gun Buy-Backs - March 9, 2013
- Defending Gun Rights With Civil Disobedience - March 2, 2013
- Bensalem Gun Buyback (video) - February 19, 2013
- Occupy Philadelphia: The Kick That the Left Really Needed - October 17, 2011
- No 9/11 Conspiracy Says Stratfor's George Friedman - September 6, 2011
- Focus on Peace's First Action - March 22, 2011
- Focus on Peace: A Peace Movement for Everyone - March 6, 2011
- The Judicial Crackdown on Jury Rights Activists in Florida - February 3, 2011
- Why They Torture (video) - January 29, 2011
- Martin Luther King and the Empowerment of the War Machine: A Libertarian’s View (video) - January 18, 2011
- The Empire Versus the Two Julians, Assange and Heicklen, and the Anti War Activists - January 15, 2011
- The Stripping of Freedom: A Careful Scan of TSA Security Procedures (video) - January 7, 2011
- “They’re Democrats here!” - November 8, 2010
- An Inclusive Antiwar Movement? - November 4, 2010
- Jury Nullification May Be The Only Salvation For The Antiwar Activists - October 6, 2010
- Philadelphia Libertarians and Socialists Protest the FBI's Raids on Antiwar Activists (video) - September 29, 2010
- Principled Nonvoting: The Beginning of Disengaging From the State - September 16, 2010
- Unity at a Peace Rally - September 12, 2010
- Judging The George Donnelly Case - September 3, 2010
- Why Philadelphia’s Licensing and Taxing of Blogs is Creeping Fascism - August 27, 2010
- Liberty on Tour in Philadelphia, 8/14/2010 - August 17, 2010
- FIJA Activist Julian Heicklen Busted Again in NY, 8/4/2010 - August 5, 2010
- Tell Me Again, Who Can't Film on Federal Property? - July 5, 2010
- The Nightmare Financial Regulatory Scheme - June 27, 2010
- Police State New York: Video of Heicklen’s Arrest 6/14/2010 - June 21, 2010
- Seattle's Blue Gang Extortion Racket - June 18, 2010
- Oh, Come, All Ye Hateful - June 9, 2010
- Global Ecosystemic Meltdown! - February 28, 2010
- Oaths, War, And Liberty - May 11, 2009
- Drug Prohibition: Law Enforcement Is The Problem - April 26, 2009
- How Dare You Want To Know What “Your” Government Is Doing! - April 11, 2009
- The Guilty Small Fries Had Their Part In The Meltdown Too - March 23, 2009
- Rationalization: Scary And All Too Present These Days - February 27, 2009
- Obama’s Karn Evil - February 25, 2009
- Recovery Depends on Investment and Capital Accumulation - January 27, 2009
- An Economy On Life Support Is Not Recovering - January 20, 2009
- Krugman’s War On Liberty - January 10, 2009
- Obixon - November 2, 2008
- An Open letter to CBS - October 29, 2008
- Confusion About Government at the Huffington Post - October 1, 2008
- The Conservative Takeover of the Libertarian Party - September 27, 2008
- Bail Out or Power Grab? - September 21, 2008
- Did McCain Choose Palin to Forestall NRA Endorsement of Barr? - August 31, 2008