As the Occupy Movement enters its second month and the weather starts to get colder, analysts and pundits are struggling to figure out what they actually hope to accomplish with their 24/7 protest camps. Michael Kinsley has attempted to trivialize the movement’s ultimate goals down to a short list of four tax proposals. Tax Proposals?! Has he even been paying attention?! Chris Satullo from WHYY (an NPR affiliate in Philadelphia) seems to believe that the movement is all about Healthcare and jobs, which only further demonstrates how media pundits on the Left and the Right simply have no clue what all this is about!
My Microeconomics students have also had questions as to where this might be going. As an Adjunct Professor at a Community College, the majority of my students have a lot in common with the protestors. They’re young, they’re either unemployed or underemployed, and they have no idea whether they’ll be able to apply anything they’re learning in my class in a real job, or will they be flipping burgers and wondering whether they’ll ever be able to pay back their Student Loans.
Candice, a student in my Microeconomics class, confessed to me that after spending a lot of time online at various “Occupy” websites and newsfeeds that she’s more confused about the Movement’s goals than ever.
I understand they feel like we are in an economic spiral downward and that there is corruption going on with Wall Street banks and the government but is there any clear motive stated? I found that they are upset because some of the biggest companies are paying a low share of national income…But I can’t find any clear goals or is this just to bring awareness and hope for a change?
In my response to Candice, I assured her that there is more than just “hope for change”, but I really believe that real change is ultimately on its way. However, unlike other movements of the past, this group’s goals appear to be growing more organically as the answer to the core causes of this crisis become more clear.
I see the Occupy Movement moving towards two ultimate goals, and it pleases me that despite the efforts of the media and the political elite to try to steer the protestors in a particular direction to their own ends, it is pretty clear to me that this is the direction the movement is heading. It basically comes down to two goals: 1) Amend the Constitution and 2) Change the Monetary System.
What’s interesting about these two goals is that the resistance to these two ideas is starting to fall apart, which will leave a vacuum for these ultimate goals to form. In other words, it’s already clear that the government cannot function due to corporate corruption and the more that the government attempts to “rescue” its corporate masters, the more it will be unable to function as a legitimate political state. There is no doubt that the American Empire is in decline and when it falls, there needs to be a new mechanism that will prevent its Citizens from falling into chaos.
Goal #1: A Constitutional Convention
This change to the Constitution will end Corporate “personhood” and remove the notion that “money” is the same as “speech” in this country. Other Amendments may be term limits on those serving in Congress, a Balanced Budget Amendment, or Abolishing the Income Tax, but the one that has the best chance of “sticking” is the first one. We cannot count on Congress to propose these Amendments because it would cut off the “gravy train” of their campaign finance, so Occupy Movement will instead hold a Constitutional Convention under the terms of Article V of the Constitution.
Ironically, the Convention is already scheduled for July through October of 2012. Although at this point they are keeping the agenda and the goals of the Convention out of the press. At the moment, they’re saying that it’ll be a Convention to bring together representatives from all of the Occupy Movements from around the Country for “solidarity”, but those of us who have been following the movement can see where this is going. A lot is going to happen between now and next July that I’m sure will solidify this ultimate agenda. It’s ironic that Philadelphia has been chosen as the location for this Convention – after all, isn’t it here where it all started?
Goal #2: Changing the Monetary System
While many in the movement will disagree that this is an ultimate goal, it’s certainly heading in that direction, and it’s a good thing. The insistence by so many well-meaning people that ending fiat money is just a Libertarian pipe-dream only hammers home how indoctrinated the people are that the current system must be the best when that couldn’t be further from the truth.
One of the primary causes – and likely THE cause of the income disparity in this country and the rest of the world is the role that Central Banks have to print endless amounts of currency out of whole cloth. This practice erodes the wealth of the poor and working classes while at the same time enriches those who have direct access to wealth and power.
For those discouraged Libertarians out there who are frustrated that the #OWS people are calling you “Ron Paul Ideologues”, don’t worry, many of them are already starting to come around and given time I’m sure they’ll start seeing things differently.
We’re already starting to see “cashless” monetary systems starting to spring up in social media networks while people like Ron Paul and his supporters are calling for abolishing the Fed. Just understand that this is a tough pill for ordinary people to swallow as they have been indoctrinated to believe that the Fed actually “controls” inflation and “ensures” full employment through its ability to print money, but all one has to do is look at the state of the poor and underemployed around the world to see that this notion is clearly false.
Some have suggested that we go to a currency pegged on Gold and other precious metals, while others have suggested that it would be better that currency should take on a more “organic” form through a system of barter and trade via social media. The “Gold Standard” is a political hot button, and the barter “bank” system I’ve seen looks a bit too anarchistic for most people’s tastes, so I’m not sure which system would work. The one thing I am sure of is that the current system is going to eventually implode, and there had better be something there to take its place when it does.
More Than Just Hope
For those protestors who are willing to brave the New York winter (some of whom don’t have a choice), boiling down their goals to a short list of tax proposals that have a snowball’s chance of ever passing in Congress trivializes and insults their resolve to see real change happen in this country. What we all seem to know intuitively is that the current regime is weaker than it has ever been in its history, and if we do not wish for our cities to descend into anarchy when the current regime collapses, we need something in its place to take over as the new legitimate power.
Ultimately, the choice is up to you. If you decide to bury your head in the sand and insist that the government will work itself out, then what you’re choosing is a world of violence and anarchy, which may lead to the rise of a military dictatorship as we have seen too many times in our history. I’d like to believe that it doesn’t have to be that way.
Your other option is to can give your support to the People of this Country to introduce a new paradigm on how things can be done. If there are enough of us out there who believe that this can be done peacefully and organically – without populist leaders and doom prophets – then there’s a chance we can at least minimize the chaos that is sure to come when the American Empire ultimately falls under its own weight.
We cannot go back to the way things were – we can just move forward.Tweet
Latest posts by Bill Gee (see all)
- A Splash of Cold Water - October 16, 2013
- Sallie Mae Leaves ALEC - September 10, 2013
- Insult to Injury - May 15, 2013
- Macroeconomics 204 - March 18, 2013
- The 10K College Degree - February 26, 2013
- Star Wars and the MIC - February 22, 2013
- Preppers vs Pragmatists - February 15, 2013
- My Thoughts on the Fiscal Cliff - December 10, 2012
- US Treasury Bond Shortage - December 4, 2012
- Weaknesses in Fair-Value Accounting for Investments - November 20, 2012
- Made in Myanmar - November 19, 2012
- It's Time for a People's Party! - November 8, 2012
- The Chicago Plan Evaluated - October 26, 2012
- Five Stories Of Our Impending Economic Collapse - October 10, 2012
- What Bain Capital Owns - August 31, 2012
- The Most Boring Election Season EVER! - August 15, 2012
- And There Was Much Rejoicing… - July 26, 2012
- Are Business Schools Actually Schools of Crime? - July 17, 2012
- ECB Stimulus Inspiring Confidence?You're Kidding, Right? - July 13, 2012
- Wal-Mart vs. Morons Rebuttal - July 10, 2012
- Notes on the Economy – February 2012 - February 28, 2012
- Fraud and Financial Regulation - February 15, 2012
- Employee Well-Being Matters - February 14, 2012
- Notes on the Economy – January 2012 - February 1, 2012
- SOPA and Nolan Chart - January 17, 2012
- “The Big Waste” and Food Network - January 10, 2012
- Bleak Outlook for the Insurance Industry - December 29, 2011
- Notes on the Economy – December 2011 - December 28, 2011
- My 2011 “Top Ten” - December 16, 2011
- The Minimum Wage Debate - December 13, 2011
- Credit-Default Swaps ARE Insurance - December 9, 2011
- OWS “Gone Underground” - December 7, 2011
- Why the Occupy “Camps” Are Important - November 30, 2011
- Whitman To Protestors – “If You Want Change, Vote For It!” - November 1, 2011
- News From the Front Lines – Oct 24-28 - October 28, 2011
- New Derivative Instrument – US Treasury Bonds? - October 24, 2011
- What Will Occupy Wall Street Actually Accomplish? - October 21, 2011
- Orszag to Protestors: “It's Not My Fault!” - October 19, 2011
- Occupy Trenton Shut Down by Authorities - October 18, 2011
- The NYC Declaration - October 13, 2011
- Occupy Wall Street's List of Demands - October 11, 2011
- Nolan Chart – Get Off Your Butts! - October 6, 2011
- Support “Occupy Wall Street” - October 4, 2011
- Notes on the Economy – Sept 19 – 23 - September 23, 2011
- Protecting Your Assets Against Inflation - September 16, 2011
- Sustainable Eating Part 2: Vegetarian Awareness Month - September 9, 2011
- Worthless Treasury Bonds - September 6, 2011
- The Story of Darcy Flynn - August 31, 2011
- Sustainable Eating – Good for Your Health, the Environment & Your Wallet - August 23, 2011
- London Riot Controversy – A Preview for Us? - August 18, 2011
- Growing Our Way to Prosperity? - August 15, 2011
- Clutching At Straws - August 12, 2011
- Civil Unrest in Olde London Towne - August 9, 2011
- Batten Down the Hatches! - August 5, 2011
- Economic Crisis and the Normalcy Bias - August 2, 2011
- How Treasury Bonds Work – A Quick Lesson - July 28, 2011
- Pay For Performance – The Failed Experiment - July 26, 2011
- The Last Hope for the Euro - July 21, 2011
- Legislating CurriculumOr Why Kids Hate Social Studies - July 20, 2011
- Productive Efficiency and Reality TV - July 18, 2011
- The “Grand Bargain” Myth - July 12, 2011
- The Culture of Fear in the Workplace – Part 3 - July 8, 2011
- The Corporation & Personhood - July 5, 2011
- DSK – The Downfall of A Reformer - July 1, 2011
- Camden NJ – America's Fallujah (Part 5) - June 29, 2011
- Dodd-Frank is a Joke on Executive Pay - June 22, 2011
- The Fed is Powerless - June 20, 2011
- Macroeconomic Radicalization 101 - June 17, 2011
- The Soul I Left Behind: Part 2 - June 9, 2011
- The Culture of Fear in the Workplace: Part 2 - June 3, 2011
- When Crime Pays – A Marginal Economic Analysis - May 31, 2011
- The Confusing GOP Message - May 25, 2011
- The Infrastructure Time Bomb - May 23, 2011
- The Soul I Left Behind - May 20, 2011
- The End of Judicial Independence - May 19, 2011
- Death Derivatives As A Hedge On Longevity - May 18, 2011
- In Defense of the Starbucks Customer & Investor - May 17, 2011
- Investing in Armageddon - May 13, 2011
- Key Differences with the Arab Spring - May 12, 2011
- Lessons from the Arab Spring - May 9, 2011
- In Defense of the Whole Foods Customer & Investor - May 4, 2011
- Ding-Dong! Bin Laden is Dead! - May 2, 2011
- Too-Big-To-Fail Investment Banks Collusion – Again! - April 29, 2011
- New Investment Vehicle – “Death Bet Securities” - April 26, 2011
- Are We the Zero’s or the X’s? - April 25, 2011
- On the Subject of Fear - April 20, 2011
- The “Laffer Curve” is Laughable - April 14, 2011
- The Culture of Fear in the Workplace - April 12, 2011
- Why I Can't Run Away - April 4, 2011
- The World of Harry Potter Can Teach Us A Few Things - March 29, 2011
- The “Wizard of Oz” Revisited - March 28, 2011
- The First Estimates Are In: 1 Japanese Earthquake = 4 Katrinas - March 23, 2011
- The Connection Between the Japan Disaster & the US Budget Deficit - March 17, 2011
- Taxpayer Funding of the “Liberal Press” - March 14, 2011
- The “Thought Police” Have Arrived - March 9, 2011
- The Economic Consequences of Exclusion - March 8, 2011
- “Sacred Cows” that Teacher Unions Must Give Up - March 3, 2011
- New Derivative Instrument: Sovereign Credit-Default Swaps (CDSs) - March 1, 2011
- Rebuttal to “The Case For Competing Precious Metal Currencies” - February 25, 2011
- Hungry People Are Angry People - February 23, 2011
- Common Ground: Infrastructure – but High-Speed Rail? - February 17, 2011
- Response to Rebuttal to “Reserve-Based Currency vs. Precious Metals-Based Currency (Part 1)” - February 14, 2011
- Reserve-Based Currency vs. Precious Metals-Based Currency (Part 1) - February 10, 2011
- Message to Youth: Create Your Own Jobs! - February 8, 2011
- The Usefulness of “Utility” - February 1, 2011
- How Is Art an Example of Government Waste? - January 31, 2011
- Is Austerity Doomed? - January 28, 2011
- Camden – America's Next Fallujah? (Part 4) - January 25, 2011
- The Muni-Bond Market's “House of Cards” - January 24, 2011
- Camden – America's Next Fallujah? (Part 3) - January 21, 2011
- Camden – America's Next Fallujah? (Part 2) - January 20, 2011
- Camden, NJ – America's Fallujah? - January 18, 2011
- “Blood Libel” Claim Casts Sarah Palin as the Victim in Tucson Shooting - January 14, 2011
- Let's Find Some Middle Ground on Gun Control (Part II) - January 13, 2011
- Let's Find Some Middle Ground on Gun Control - January 12, 2011
- Obama's “Oklamoma City Moment” - January 11, 2011
- Turn Down the Volume - January 10, 2011