Q. Where, in the Constitution, is there mention of education?
A. There is none; education is a matter reserved for the States.
(U.S. National Archives website)
by R. Lee Wrights
BURNET, Texas (Sept. 24) – The federal education program No Child Left Behind is leaving behind the very children it was supposedly designed to help. The law dictates that all elementary and secondary school children in government-run public schools be “proficient” in reading and math by 2014, according to standards set by politicians and federal bureaucrats. According to President Obama’s secretary of education, most of the nation’s schools are on the brink of getting a failing grade. Nearly 80 percent of schools are in danger of losing their federal funding, leaving the children in their classrooms behind for “failing” to meet bureaucratic standards.
President George W. Bush came up with this program and a Republican Congress passed it in 2002. This is apparently one of the few failures President Barack Obama doesn’t blame on his Republican predecessors. The president and his Secretary of Education Arne Duncan have decided fix the problem by allowing states to do what some have already tried to do – opt out of the federal mandate.
So here you have yet another federal government program that is not only unconstitutional but also an utter and complete failure. Yet rather than admitting it’s a failure and ending the program, politicians and bureaucrats insist on trying to “fix it.” However, the alleged fix is just a subterfuge for imposing standards the administration had already written but couldn’t get Congress to pass. This is another example of the dictatorial style used by modern American presidents from both parties. It is a classic example of the ruling elites trying to conceal failure in a blatant attempt to simply save face and subvert the limits imposed by law and the Constitution to expand their power.
Several states had already tried to resist this latest federal intrusion into education. Utah’s legislature almost passed a law that said the state’s education standards trumped those of No Child Left Behind, but then backed off because the state could have lost $76 million in federal funding. Idaho, South Dakota and Montana said they’d ignore parts of the law. Michigan, Tennessee and Kentucky applied for waivers even before they were announced. All of these states were close to being labeled “failing.”
Given this trend, I think it is a good bet that a majority of the states will attempt to opt-out of this federal burden. However, the “waivers” Secretary Duncan will dangle in front of the states will come with the usual strings attached, making it difficult for states to actually obtain these waivers. As a result, it’s very likely that only those states with passing grades will be left subject to the law. This will so skew the grades that federal education apparatchiks will be able to finally declare that No Child Left Behind is a success.
In defending No Child Left Behind, President Obama was right about one thing. He said, “Making a promise to educate every child with an excellent teacher, that’s the right thing to do, that’s the right goal.” The issue is not whether or not we want our children to have excellent teachers and a first-rate education. Of course we do. The question is whether parents can, or should, rely on government to provide it, or rather assume the responsibility themselves. The libertarian answer to that question is clear: nothing as important as educating a child should be left to bumbling bureaucrats.
The No Child Left Behind bungle is another situation where a government-run public education system doesn’t get a passing grade, at any level. One out of every three students entering high school doesn’t graduate. Minority students are twice as likely as whites to drop out. Even students who get their diploma have the reading and math skills expected of middle school students in other nations.
The worst consequence of taking the responsibility for educating young minds from parents and bestowing it on the State is that the task is botched so horribly. Some children are educated quite well in a state-supported system but most barely receive an average level of education. And, far too many fall through the expansive cracks of society that are the floorboards of a bloated bureaucracy grown so large it has become impossible to keep track of everyone.
Government-run education is a twelve-year “cookie-cutter” factory system that treats everyone the same and produces more than its fair share of functional illiterates. Secretary Duncan admitted as much when he said, “”No Child Left Behind treated everybody the same, as interchangeable, and that just doesn’t make any sense to me.” I am glad he thinks so! It never has made any sense to me.
But that is what government programs inherently do. They are intentionally designed that way, to always threat everyone and everything “the same.” They cannot operate any other way. Deciding educational issue by majority vote inevitably results in “dumbing-down” what is taught. Children in government-run public schools are not educated, they are indoctrinated. These children are not trained to take charge of governing themselves; but rather, they are almost programmed to be willing taxpayers who obey a ruling elite.
A child’s first and most important teachers are his or her parents. What a child learns and where he or she learns it is a decision best made by parents, not politicians, bureaucrats or educational experts. The most important thing we can do for the education of our children is to return the responsibility for that education to whom it belongs, to parents.
We should also restore to parents the means to afford the best education possible for their children by eliminating the property taxes that support failing, government-run public schools and repealing the income tax. If parents want their child to pray in school, to learn evolution or creationism, get sex education or learn abstinence, and not be harassed by bullies, they should have the means and ability to choose the school that best meets these needs. They should be able to send their children to a school that conforms to their family values and standards, not the values and standards imposed by distant and detached education “experts.” If we really want to leave no child behind we will eliminate the political experts from the educational equation, because they have already proven they are unable to deliver what they promise.
R. Lee Wrights, 53, a libertarian writer and political activist, is seeking the presidential nomination because he believes the Libertarian message in 2012 must be a loud, clear and unequivocal call to stop all war. To that end he has pledged that 10 percent of all donations to his campaign will be spent for ballot access so that the stop all war message can be heard in all 50 states. Wrights is a lifetime member of the Libertarian Party and co-founder and editor of the free speech online magazine Liberty For All. Born in Winston-Salem, N.C., he now lives and works in Texas.Tweet
Latest posts by Brian Irving (see all)
- Presidential candidates should read the job description - November 5, 2011
- Why I Am Not Running for President - October 29, 2011
- The sun never sets on the U.S. military - October 22, 2011
- Dr. Mary Ruwart endorses Lee Wrights for president - October 21, 2011
- War breeds war. Peace breeds prosperity. - October 15, 2011
- Republicans don't support all the troops - October 8, 2011
- Nothing good grows at the Department of Agriculture - October 1, 2011
- No Child Left Behind is leaving all children behind - September 24, 2011
- Waste and fraud pervade wartime contracting - September 17, 2011
- Ten years of fear is enough - September 7, 2011
- U.S. Constitution Day Resolution - August 29, 2011
- Decriminalizing drugs will save lives and money - August 24, 2011
- The most destructive war in American history - August 15, 2011
- Communist Party chair endorses voting for 'lesser of two evils' - August 7, 2011
- Voting for the lesser of two evils - August 3, 2011
- The manufacture and manipulation of fear - July 23, 2011
- The Wasted Vote Lie - July 12, 2011
- Wrights joins call to end to U.S. militarism - July 6, 2011
- Reviving the Spirit of '76 - July 2, 2011
- Don't raise the debt ceiling, stop the spending. - June 27, 2011
- Group rights are a dangerious illusion - June 13, 2011
- N.C. House passes bill to lower ballot access barriers - June 8, 2011
- Patriot Act renewal gives terrorists another victory - June 1, 2011
- Illegal immigrants are nullifying a bad law - May 23, 2011
- The most dangerous man in the world - May 11, 2011
- The killing of Osama bin Laden - May 3, 2011
- Another president blindly taking us “knee deep in the big muddy” - April 27, 2011
- Wrights to seek Libertarian presidential nomination - April 16, 2011
- Stop the war on dying cancer patients - April 13, 2011
- Military tribunals are an affront to the Constitution - April 6, 2011
- Lies, damn lies and presidential statements - March 31, 2011
- Obama takes the Nobel Peace Prize to war - March 28, 2011
- President Obama contradicts Sen.Obama again - March 25, 2011
- Bombs fall on the evil and the innocent - March 22, 2011
- Any US attack on Libya would be unconstitutional and despicable - March 19, 2011
- N.C. Supreme Court upholds restrictive ballot access law - March 16, 2011
- 'Nosy neighbor' foreign policy creates enemies - March 15, 2011
- Defending the Constitution means not enforcing unconstitutional laws - March 6, 2011
- Opposing war doesn't make you a pacifist - February 27, 2011
- War is not the answer - February 16, 2011
- NC bill would lower election barriers for third parties,unaffiliated candidates - February 7, 2011
- Who rules Egypt is none of our business - February 7, 2011
- Wrights takes 'stop all war' message to Arizona - January 31, 2011
- The state of the union is still a state of war - January 28, 2011
- N.C. Libertarians withdraw from LNC region - January 25, 2011
- War is not moral - January 25, 2011
- Blame Arizona shooting on the shooter - January 13, 2011
- N.C. Libertarians condemn FBI raids on anti-war activists - January 3, 2011
- Wright's resolutions for 2011 – a declaration of peace - December 31, 2010
- Christmas present to the troops – bring them home - December 24, 2010
- Reaction to WikiLeaks threatens liberty - December 16, 2010
- Wrights pledges 'wise and frugal' principled campaign - December 6, 2010
- Rangel censure another incredible Congressional sham - December 4, 2010
- Airport security theater is a bad play for liberty - November 30, 2010
- David Nolan: The Soul of the Libertarian Party - November 23, 2010
- Stop the spending - November 21, 2010
- One million Americans voted Libertarian - November 9, 2010
- U.S. Senate hopeful asked the hard questions - November 5, 2010
- Win or lose, Libertarian candidates make a difference - October 31, 2010
- Anti-war liberals should vote Libertarian - October 29, 2010
- Wars consume our most precious resource - October 12, 2010
- Afghan war will cost another $60 billion - September 27, 2010
- NC Supreme Court hears arguments in ballot access case - September 9, 2010
- Don't just turn the page, close the book on Iraq war - September 2, 2010
- True cost of war - August 30, 2010
- U.S. court upholds another restrictive ballot access laws - August 27, 2010
- NY mosque issue hijacked for political expediency - August 20, 2010
- This Republican governor actually said 'no' to big government - August 18, 2010
- Judge may rule soon in NC ballot access case - August 14, 2010
- NC ends discrimination in political party financing fund - August 7, 2010
- N.C. Supreme Court to hear Libertarian-Green challenge to state's restrictive ballot access laws - July 28, 2010
- NC Attorney Generalwants your DNA - June 10, 2010
- Repeal of'don t ask, don't tell' policy is a civil rights issue - June 8, 2010
- What does it mean to be a 'nation of immigrants?' - May 7, 2010
- Immigrants used as scapegoats for problems caused by big government - April 28, 2010
- NC company goes green — with taxpayer money - April 21, 2010
- NC city fights for right to hold non-partisan elections - April 14, 2010
- NC Libertarians offer prescription for ‘big government’ disease - April 13, 2010
- Removing N.C. ballot access restrictions an issue that transcends political differences - March 18, 2010
- Historic ballot access lawsuit reaches N.C. Supreme Court - March 15, 2010
- Without Power, There Can Be No Corruption - November 9, 2009
- NC Libertarians stay on ballot - November 5, 2008
- Munger closing campaign with back roads tour - November 1, 2008
- Cole: Waddling Debt is a Duck - September 22, 2008
- Munger Responds to NC Education Forum ‘Debate’ - September 19, 2008
- The Liberty Agenda for North Carolina - September 15, 2008
- The Tree of Liberty Needs Watering - July 10, 2008