Ron Paul’s recent idea on how to ease the national debt is hardly original but none the less worthy of consideration. He has proposed what leftist critics of the status quo monetary system have been proposing for decades: that money printing should be used to fund the government.
To give Ron due credit, he is not proposing exactly that. More precisely, he is proposing that the Fed should tear up a bundle of its Treasury securities, which would lower our overall debt total bringing us below the current debt ceiling.
Still, the mechanics are identical, if not in reverse order. Far left liberals have correctly criticized the fiat system of money production as benefiting the banking and elite wealth interests while disadvantaging the poor. Their solution, at least those who aren’t anarchists, has always been to free up money production as a method of directly funding the state or for that matter, the states, alleviating the interest and debt that is synonymous with our current system.
The interest on the particular notes in question, since they are entitled to the Federal Reserve is in a practical sense already extinguished. The Fed is required at the end of the year to turn in its profits to the Treasury. The Fed makes good money on the interest it collects from the Treasury during the year from all the government paper it has in its possession. In this sense, the Treasury has already stopped paying interest on the bonds the Fed owns, since the interest is the Feds profit, which by law must be returned to the Treasury.
Opponents of Ron’s idea believe that if the Fed torched a pile of its government securities that it would lose the ability to withdraw money from the economy. The Fed does this by selling securities and hoarding the greenbacks it gathers from the proceeds of the sales.
The truth is the Fed does not lose its ability to suck money out of the economy until it relinquishes all its paper assets. As long as it has something to sell, it can pull money from the economy and store the greenbacks in its vaults.
We can also take Paul’s idea one step further and approach this dilemma from another angle. The Fed could actually purchase brand new Treasury securities without paying the government one dime. It could then sell those securities and deposit the cash. Since the Fed must turn in its profits, much of the cash would end up back in the hands of the government at the end of the year, but without any new money creation and again; a lower debt amount.
Pauls idea or the left monetary critique ideas aren’t nonsensical; they actually make perfect sense relative to the monetary system. Of course, that isn’t saying that much.
On the other hand, it all makes perfect sense: if you happen to be on the receiving end of the Fed’s graciousness. Problem is, very few of us are.
The merits of Pauls idea should be judged individually. If Paul stands for the common man as he claims, then we can judge his suggestions based on that premise. How would extinguishing a chunk of the federal debt affect the average fellow?
Taking the entire financial system into consideration, the effect of Pauls idea on everyman probably wouldn’t add up to the proverbial hill of beans. The scope of the system is so massive, only wholesale change will benefit regular folks in any meaningful manner.
Extinguishing federal debt would lower interest payments, which would mean less federal revenue would be devoted to interest payments. Whether this would have much of an effect on federal expenditures is doubtful.Tweet
Latest posts by Gene DeNardo (see all)
- Equating Republicans to Anarchists is Insulting to Anarchists. - October 20, 2013
- What Happens If Government Does Not Raise the Debt Ceiling? - October 7, 2013
- How IP Laws Restrict Our Freedom. - March 3, 2013
- Fiat Money Production and Environmental Degradation. - February 17, 2013
- When Laws Are Illegitimate - November 25, 2012
- Profits Rise While Unemployment Remains High. - October 17, 2012
- The Capital Gains Tax. - October 13, 2012
- Monetary and Price Inflation: Understanding the Difference. - October 7, 2012
- Mortgage Backed Securities Back in Favor? - September 28, 2012
- Bush Tax Cuts: Coming Around the Bend! - September 1, 2012
- Towards A Better Understanding of the Nature of Profit. - August 4, 2012
- Are You a State Socialist? - July 21, 2012
- How Cartelization of the Health Care Industry Socializes Insurance. - July 14, 2012
- The Health Care Mandate Is A Tax. - July 1, 2012
- A Document Is Not Always A Contract. - June 12, 2012
- Same Sex Marriage, Missing the Real Issue. - May 11, 2012
- Is Corporate Greed the Problem? - October 30, 2011
- Corporate Personhood and the Occupy Wall Street Movement. - October 15, 2011
- The Feasibility of a “Night Watchman State”. - September 18, 2011
- Should We Tax “The Heck Out Of The Rich”? - July 22, 2011
- Should The Fed Burn A Pile Of Treasury Securities? - July 9, 2011
- Are You Morally Obliged to Pay Your Mortgage? - June 29, 2011
- The Deficit Debate That Isn't! - April 16, 2011
- Quantitative Easing ll, Deflation and Inflation. - November 17, 2010
- The Fed Asks Selected Traders, How Much Money Do You Want and When? - October 31, 2010
- 50 State Attorney Generals to Investigate Foreclosure Paperwork Crisis. - October 16, 2010
- Title Companies May be Next to Enter Foreclosure Fray - October 6, 2010
- Bank of America halts foreclosures in 23 States. - October 2, 2010
- GMAC Mortgage in Hot Water with the Courts. - September 25, 2010
- MERS, the Hidden Link of the Housing Crisis. - September 12, 2010
- Quarterly Bank Revenue Numbers Come in Bipolar. - September 1, 2010
- Local Health Officials Close Down Little Girl's Lemonade Stand! - August 9, 2010
- Forbe's Top Ten Industries - July 9, 2010
- Acknowledging the Difference Between State Socialism and Economic Fascism in Governments. - July 4, 2010
- Is Financial Regulation Feasible? - June 26, 2010
- Libertarianism: Left and Right - June 6, 2010
- Deep Water Drilling and Nonexistant Royalties. - May 18, 2010
- The Federal Reserve and Income Tax: Working in Tandem or Seperate Institutions? - April 22, 2010
- The United States Forest Service and the Spotted Owl! - October 13, 2009
- Secured and Unsecured Debt. The Differences Are Not So Obvious. - September 24, 2009
- Tragedy of the Collective - September 13, 2009
- Oregon Experiences Double Digit Health Insurance Rate Increases. - September 9, 2009
- Missed Tax Reform Opportunity for Liberals and Conservatives. - September 5, 2009
- Psuedo Competition Within the Health Care Industry. - August 16, 2009
- Clunkers and the Environment - August 11, 2009
- American Health Care and the Intrusion of Insurance. - August 6, 2009
- Do Systems Development Fees Really Work? - July 30, 2009
- Flat Tax? We already have one! - June 5, 2009
- Health Care Cartel Announces Price Cut - May 15, 2009
- The Last Great Recession - March 28, 2009
- Infrastructure and State Socialism - January 27, 2009
- Theories of Value and the Recent Downturn - January 23, 2009
- Banking: Deposits and Investment - January 18, 2009
- Banking Part Two: Demand Deposits - January 14, 2009
- Banking Basics. - January 9, 2009
- The Bush Doctrine. - December 22, 2008
- MV=PT A Classic Equation and Monetary Policy - December 7, 2008